Performance optimization: Deleting inventory journal lines

Preamble

As a developer, you should always consider performance implications of the code you write. In an ERP application like Microsoft Dynamics AX, the main focus should be on query execution, since it takes up the overwhelming part of the servers' resources.

You should always write queries that would execute the minimum amount of time and use the minimum amount of resources, at the same time producing the expected output in all cases.

Note, that performance is one of those things you cannot really verify on a 1-box install with a small test dataset. Most query problems show up only when tested with many users concurrently loading the AOS on a large-size database.

Code example

Table method
AOT\Data Dictionary\Tables\InventJournalTrans\Methods\delete
contains the following code:

    if (this.Voucher)
    {
        if (this.numOfVoucherLines() == 0)
            JournalError::deleteVoucher(tablenum(InventJournalTable),this.JournalId,this.Voucher);
    }

The code is logically correct, deleting related records from the JournalError table, which contains error messages generated during validation and posting of journals.
But now let us consider the actual implementation. If we rephrase the conditions under which we delete the error message history, it would sound something like:

If a Voucher number is specified on the line being deleted, and there is no more lines in this journal that use this Voucher number, then we remove the JournalError records.

Deeper code analysis for performance

So, let's go in deeper, and open the code for method numOfVoucherLines:

Integer numOfVoucherLines()
{
    return any2int((select count(RecId) from inventJournalTrans
                      where inventJournalTrans.JournalId == this.JournalId &&
                            inventJournalTrans.Voucher   == this.Voucher).RecId);
}

As you can see, it counts all the journal lines with the specified Voucher number and JournalId.
Does it generate the expected output? Yes.
Is it optimal for the scenario in which it is used? No.

In order to determine if JournalError records can be deleted, we only need to know if at least 1 record with the specified Voucher number exists. So why do we need to search and count all such records? We don't.
Note that this code is being executed for each journal line, magnifying the impact of a non-optimal query N-fold.

Suggested solution

So, if we create a new method like this:

boolean voucherLineExist()
{
    return (select firstfast firstonly forceplaceholders recId from inventJournalTrans
            index hint VoucherIdx
            where inventJournalTrans.journalId == this.journalId &&
                  inventJournalTrans.voucher   == this.voucher).recId != 0;
}

and use it instead of numOfVoucherLines() in delete() method, we will greatly improve the overall performance when deleting journal lines.
It has been measured, that the time it takes to delete a journal with a large number of lines (88000, to be specific) has reduced by 6 times, which is fantastic.

Notes

• forceplaceholders is used in the query explicitly to make sure a query plan is created and reused for this query, which further improves the performance, since the Voucher number most probably changes from line to line (depends on related journal name setup).
• It is generally still a best practice to avoid creating inventory journals with such a large number of rows, because the journal is usually processed in 1 database transaction.

See also

• Link to AxForum, where this problem was originally reported and solution suggested.
• Link to Microsoft Dynamics AX Performance team blog, containing useful information about performance tuning and tools